Your cat stares at you with those irresistible eyes, and you cave. You offer a treat because it feels like an expression of love, a small reward for existing in your home. The problem: most commercial cat treats are nutritional disasters—high in fillers, low in protein, and designed more to appeal to humans opening packages than to benefit your cat.
After examining hundreds of commercial cat treats and testing alternatives, I've discovered that "healthy cat treat" doesn't have to be an oxymoron. It's possible to reward your cat while actually improving her diet instead of sabotaging it.
The Problem with Commercial Cat Treats
Before discussing solutions, let's understand why most commercial treats are problematic.
Cats are obligate carnivores. Their digestive systems evolved to process meat, not grains or fillers. Yet many commercial treats contain:
- Corn and corn byproducts (cheap fillers with minimal nutritional value)
- Wheat and wheat gluten (allergenic for many cats)
- Soy (estrogen-like compounds with potential health implications)
- Excessive carbohydrates (which cats can't efficiently process)
- Low meat content (meat appears late in ingredient lists)
These treats often provide less than 10% of daily caloric intake in terms of actual nutrients. For a 10-pound cat eating 250 calories daily, treats might provide 25-50 calories of junk.
Additionally, many commercial treats are high in sodium and artificial flavors—designed to be irresistible to cats rather than healthy for them.
You Might Also Enjoy
- DIY Catnip Treats Your Cat Will Go Crazy For
- Using Treats for Medication: How to Hide Pills in Food Your Pet Will Eat
- 5 Healthy Homemade Dog Treat Recipes Your Pup Will Love
- The Best Training Treats for Dogs: Small, Tasty, and Effective
Evaluating Commercial Treats
If you choose commercial treats, evaluate them rigorously. Read labels carefully.
Quality indicators:
- Named meat source first: "Chicken" or "fish" should be the first ingredient, not "meat meal" or "animal byproducts"
- High protein: At least 30% crude protein
- Low carbohydrates: Less than 10% carbs ideally
- No fillers: Avoid corn, wheat, soy, and corn syrup
- Minimal sodium: Should be relatively low, not a significant portion of daily intake
- No artificial flavors or colors: These are unnecessary and potentially harmful
Some quality commercial brands maintain these standards. The AAFCO provides guidelines for pet food ingredients (though they're minimally regulated for "treats," which fall outside AAFCO's typical jurisdiction).
Protein-Based Commercial Treats
The best commercial treats emphasize meat:
Freeze-dried meat treats: These are simply meat (chicken, beef, fish) that's been freeze-dried to preserve freshness without processing. They're pure protein with zero fillers. Examples include freeze-dried chicken, turkey, or fish treats. Cost is higher but nutritional value is excellent.
Jerky-style treats: Some companies produce cat-appropriate jerky—dried meat with minimal processing. Read labels to ensure no added sugars or excessive sodium.
High-protein kibble treats: Some brands produce high-protein, low-carb kibble-style treats formulated as actual nutrition rather than junk. These work well as partial meal replacements or training rewards.
The downside: these quality treats cost more than junk brands. The tradeoff is worth it.
DIY Treat Options
Making treats at home gives you complete control over ingredients:
Plain cooked meat: Simply cook chicken, turkey, or beef without seasonings. Cut into small pieces. Store in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. Cats love this, and it's pure nutrition.
Fish: Cook salmon or other fish without salt or oil. Serve in small pieces. The omega-3 content provides genuine health benefits. Some cats will happily accept this as-is; others prefer it mixed with their regular food.
Broth: Homemade bone broth (simmered bones for 12-24 hours) provides collagen and minerals. Strain completely, cool, and freeze in small portions. Offer as an occasional treat.
Egg: Soft-boiled or scrambled eggs (without butter or salt) provide excellent nutrition. Some cats enjoy these; others find them unappetizing.
Meat-based popsicles: Freeze broth or cooked meat juice in ice cube trays. Some cats enjoy licking these in warm weather.
The advantage: you know exactly what your cat is eating. The disadvantage: requires more effort and planning.
Portion Control and Treat Frequency
Proper portions matter tremendously. A single freeze-dried chicken treat might be 5 calories. A larger commercial treat might be 20+ calories. For a 10-pound cat with a 250-calorie daily diet, 10 freeze-dried treats fit within the 10% guideline. Three larger commercial treats might exceed it.
Guidelines:
- Treat frequency: Daily treats are fine if portioned appropriately
- Training treats: Can be more frequent during training (using tiny portions)
- Portion size: Should be roughly the size of a pea to a small marble, depending on treat density
- Monitoring: Weigh your cat monthly. If weight creeps up, reduce treat quantity
Many owners underestimate treat portions. A treat that seems tiny to human perspective might be substantial for a 10-pound cat.
Treats for Specific Health Situations
Weight management: For overweight cats, offer zero-calorie options like plain water, a lick of plain broth, or simply increased interactive play instead of treats. If you must offer treats, use tiny pieces of cooked chicken.
Dental health: Crunchy treats designed for dental benefit aren't very effective for cats (they don't chew like dogs do), but some options might provide minimal benefit. However, regular brushing is far more effective for dental health.
Senior cats: These often benefit from softer treats or treats containing joint-supporting nutrients. Freeze-dried meat (soft despite being freeze-dried) works well.
Sensitive digestion: Plain, simple proteins work best. Avoid any treats with fillers or artificial ingredients.
Cats with allergies: Make your own treats from a single protein your cat tolerates, or choose commercial treats with limited ingredients.
Treats to Absolutely Avoid
Never offer:
- Onions, garlic, or alliums: Toxic to cats
- Chocolate: Toxic, contains theobromine
- Grapes and raisins: Cause kidney failure
- Xylitol (sugar-free products): Causes severe hypoglycemia
- Caffeine: Found in coffee, tea, and chocolate
- Alcohol: Causes intoxication
- Fatty foods: Increase pancreatitis risk
- Bones: Can splinter and cause intestinal blockage
Many of these are common in human foods people mistakenly offer cats "just a taste."
Treats and Weight Management
If your cat is overweight or prone to weight gain:
- Reduce or eliminate treats
- Use meal portions as rewards rather than extra treats
- Increase interactive play for enrichment and exercise instead of food rewards
- Focus on weight management through primary diet quality
Obesity affects an estimated 30-40% of indoor cats and contributes to diabetes, joint problems, and reduced lifespan. Treating weight management seriously, including eliminating empty-calorie treats, is one of the most important health investments you can make.
Training and Behavior Modification
Treats are useful for training and behavior modification, but strategy matters:
Use tiny portions: For training, use treat pieces roughly the size of a pea. The reward isn't quantity—it's the training interaction and your attention.
Choose high-value treats: Use treats your cat loves most for important training tasks. Reserve lower-value treats for less critical rewards.
Make treats interactive: Hide treats for your cat to "hunt." This provides enrichment and exercise alongside the nutritional reward.
Stop frequently: Training sessions should be short (5-10 minutes) with frequent breaks. Tired, frustrated cats don't learn effectively.
The Human Element
Many treat-giving is really about the owner's emotional needs—showing affection through food. Recognize this dynamic and find alternative expressions of love:
- Extended play sessions
- Grooming and petting
- Training and enrichment activities
- Quality time together
Your cat doesn't need treats to feel loved. She needs your attention, interaction, and quality care.
Reading Labels Like an Expert
When evaluating commercial treats, read labels methodically:
- First three ingredients: What's the primary protein source?
- Guaranteed analysis: Is protein at least 30%? Is fat reasonable?
- Ingredient clarity: Can you identify what "meat meal" or "animal byproducts" actually are?
- Additions: Are there unnecessary fillers, colors, or artificial flavors?
- Portion recommendations: Are they realistic, or do they suggest overfeeding?
Many manufacturers design labels to obscure questionable ingredients. Learning to read them critically helps you make better choices.
The Bottom Line
Your cat doesn't need commercial treats. She needs quality nutrition from her primary diet, appropriate portions, and your engagement and affection.
If treats are part of your routine, make them count. Invest in quality (freeze-dried meat, simple homemade options) over junk. Monitor portions rigorously. Use treats as training tools and occasional rewards, not as dietary staples.
Your cat's health over the next 10-15 years depends partly on the nutritional choices you make today. Treating intelligently is one simple way to support her longevity and vitality.
Sarah Mitchell is a pet care specialist based in Portland, Oregon, with expertise in feline nutrition and health-conscious treat alternatives.
