The raw feeding debate in dog nutrition is heated. On one side, passionate advocates claim raw diets are what dogs are "meant to eat" and tout benefits like shinier coats, better digestion, and improved health. On the other side, veterinary organizations express serious concerns about nutritional imbalances, bacterial contamination, and choking hazards.
The truth, as is often the case, is more nuanced than either extreme. Raw feeding has some potential benefits, but also significant risks that responsible dog owners need to understand thoroughly before making the switch. As a pet care specialist, my job is to help you sort through the claims and evidence.
What Exactly is a Raw Diet?
Raw diets (also called BARF—Biologically Appropriate Raw Food) typically consist of:
- Raw muscle meat
- Raw organs (liver, kidneys, heart)
- Raw meaty bones
- Raw eggs
- Vegetables and supplements
- Sometimes dairy products
The theory is that this diet mimics what wild wolves would eat, providing optimal canine nutrition in the most bioavailable form.
The Claimed Benefits of Raw Feeding
Advocates cite several purported benefits, though scientific evidence for many is limited:
Improved Coat Quality Anecdotal reports suggest shinier, healthier coats on raw diets. This is likely due to higher fat content (particularly omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids) compared to some commercial foods. However, high-quality commercial diets with appropriate fat content produce the same results.
Better Digestion Raw food proponents claim improved digestion and smaller stools. Some of this may reflect that the food is less processed and has lower carbohydrate content, or it may reflect that owners switching to raw diets often improve overall pet care attention.
Lower Carbohydrate Content Raw diets are naturally lower in carbohydrates than most kibble. For some dogs, this reduction in carbs may help with weight management. However, the same result can be achieved with grain-free or lower-carb commercial diets.
Potentially Better Nutrient Bioavailability Raw proteins may be more bioavailable than cooked proteins (meaning the dog absorbs and uses more of them). This is theoretically true, but the practical difference in healthy dogs eating adequate nutrition is minimal.
The Documented Risks of Raw Feeding
The scientific and veterinary literature raises significant concerns about raw feeding:
Nutritional Imbalances This is the biggest documented problem. Research examining homemade raw diets shows that the vast majority (over 90% in some studies) are nutritionally imbalanced. Most are deficient in calcium, vitamin D, zinc, vitamin E, and other essential nutrients. Some have dangerous imbalances in calcium-to-phosphorus ratios that can cause severe skeletal problems, especially in growing puppies.
Dogs eating nutritionally imbalanced raw diets over months to years can develop:
- Bone demineralization and weakness
- Dental problems
- Immune dysfunction
- Growth abnormalities in puppies
- Metabolic bone disease
Bacterial Contamination Raw meat is a known source of pathogenic bacteria including E. coli, Salmonella, and Listeria. Studies testing raw diets have found pathogenic bacteria in a significant percentage of samples. While dogs have more robust stomach acid than humans (providing some protection), they can still develop serious infections. More concerning, they become carriers and can shed these bacteria in feces, potentially infecting humans in the household, particularly immunocompromised individuals, children, and elderly family members.
Parasitic Contamination Raw meat may contain parasites (Toxoplasma gondii, Sarcocystis, Trichinella, others). While most parasites don't harm healthy adult dogs significantly, they can cause serious illness in puppies, senior dogs, or immunocompromised dogs.
Choking and GI Obstruction Hazards Bones, particularly poultry bones, can splinter and cause:
- Choking
- Esophageal obstruction
- Gastric obstruction
- Perforation of the GI tract
Veterinary emergency clinics treat raw diet-related obstructions and perforations regularly.
Dietary Deficiency-Related Problems Long-term feeding of unbalanced raw diets can cause:
- Dilated cardiomyopathy (from taurine deficiency)
- Immune dysfunction (from zinc, vitamin E deficiency)
- Coagulopathies (from vitamin K deficiency)
- Orthopedic problems (from calcium/phosphorus imbalances)
What Veterinary Organizations Say
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA): Does not recommend raw diets due to nutritional imbalance risks and zoonotic disease concerns.
The American College of Veterinary Nutrition (ACVN): States that raw diets are associated with health risks and should only be considered if carefully formulated and balanced by a veterinary nutritionist.
The Centers for Disease Control (CDC): Recommends against raw feeding due to zoonotic disease transmission risk, particularly in households with vulnerable individuals.
If Someone Chooses to Feed Raw: Harm Reduction Strategies
If you're considering raw feeding despite these concerns, you can reduce (though not eliminate) risks:
Work with a Veterinary Nutritionist Have a board-certified veterinary nutritionist (diplomate of the American College of Veterinary Nutrition) formulate the diet. A proper diet costs more and requires professional guidance, but it's the only way to ensure nutritional completeness.
Use Commercial Raw Diets Commercial raw diets undergo quality control and are formulated to be nutritionally complete (theoretically—research suggests some commercial raw diets are also imbalanced, but quality varies by brand). Still less risky than home-formulated diets.
Do Not Feed Whole or Raw Bones Feed only ground bone or bonemeal supplements. Avoid choking and perforation hazards. This defeats some of the "natural" appeal but removes real danger.
Use Pasteurized Raw Diets Some companies now offer pasteurized raw diets—the food is gently heat-treated to reduce pathogenic bacteria while theoretically maintaining nutrient bioavailability. This compromises some raw diet ideology but addresses bacterial risk.
Implement Food Safety Protocols
- Handle raw meat with the same food safety precautions you'd use for human food
- Use separate utensils and cutting boards
- Wash hands thoroughly after handling
- Store in separate freezer sections
- Clean food bowls thoroughly immediately after use
- Keep raw food away from human food preparation areas
Maintain Regular Veterinary Care More frequent blood work and health monitoring to detect nutritional deficiencies early.
The Cost-Benefit Analysis from a Nutritional Perspective
Benefits of Raw Feeding (Evidence-Based):
- Potentially higher fat content supporting coat quality (also available in quality commercial diets)
- Lower carbohydrate content (also available in grain-free or low-carb commercial diets)
Risks of Raw Feeding (Evidence-Based):
- Nutritional imbalances (over 90% of home-formulated raw diets)
- Bacterial contamination (documented in raw meat products)
- Parasitic contamination (present in raw meat)
- Choking and obstruction hazards (documented in veterinary practices)
- Zoonotic disease transmission to humans
Alternative Approaches to Achieve Similar Goals
If your motivation for considering raw feeding is to provide optimal nutrition and reduce processed food, consider these alternatives:
High-Quality Commercial Diets Premium commercial diets from reputable companies are formulated to meet AAFCO standards, veterinary nutritionist-approved, and backed by quality control. They're safer and more balanced than home-formulated raw diets.
Commercial Raw Diets If you prefer raw, purchase commercial raw diets rather than formulating at home. They're more expensive but address some (though not all) safety concerns.
Home-Cooked Diets Formulated by a Vet Nutritionist If you prefer home-prepared food, work with a veterinary nutritionist to formulate a complete, balanced home-cooked diet. It costs more than kibble but provides better control over ingredients while ensuring nutrition.
Hybrid Approach Feed primarily quality commercial food with occasional raw additions (meats prepared fresh for the specific meal) to address the desire for fresh ingredients without completely switching diets.
Special Cases Where Raw Feeding is Particularly Risky
- Puppies: Growing dogs require precise calcium-to-phosphorus ratios; imbalance causes serious skeletal problems
- Immune-Compromised Dogs: Dogs with compromised immune systems are more vulnerable to bacterial infections from raw meat
- Households with Immunocompromised Humans: Risk of zoonotic bacterial transmission to vulnerable family members
- Dogs with GI Issues: Raw diets may worsen conditions like IBD or pancreatitis
- Senior Dogs: Older dogs are more vulnerable to both parasitic and bacterial infections
The Bottom Line
Raw feeding is based on reasonable evolutionary logic (wild dogs do eat raw meat), but the practice as commonly implemented by dog owners is risky. The evidence shows:
- Most home-formulated raw diets are nutritionally imbalanced
- Raw meat carries documented risks of pathogenic bacterial and parasitic contamination
- Raw feeding is associated with specific documented health problems in veterinary practice
- The same nutritional goals can be achieved more safely through commercial diets or veterinary nutritionist-formulated home-cooked diets
If you choose to feed raw, do so with eyes open to the documented risks, working with a veterinary nutritionist, using commercial preparations when possible, and maintaining regular veterinary oversight.
You Might Also Enjoy
- The Best Foods for Senior Dogs: Nutrition After Age Seven
- Feeding a Dog with Food Sensitivities: An Elimination Diet Guide
- Grain-Free Dog Food: Is It Really Better for Your Pet?
- Puppy Nutrition 101: Feeding Your New Dog Right from Day One
Sources:
- American Veterinary Medical Association. "Nutritional Assessment: Raw and Home-Cooked Diets." Retrieved from avma.org
- American College of Veterinary Nutrition. (2024). "Selecting Appropriate Pet Food." Retrieved from acvn.org
- Merck Veterinary Manual. "Home-Prepared and Raw Diets for Dogs and Cats." Retrieved from merckvetmanual.com
